This is the mail archive of the
mailing list for the Cygwin project.
Re: Re: courier auth+imap
- From: Marek Telgarsky <marek at telgarsky dot com>
- To: cygwin at cygwin dot com
- Date: Sat, 30 Sep 2006 22:44:09 -0500
- Subject: Re: Re: courier auth+imap
- Reply-to: marek at telgarsky dot com
Thank you for your speedy response.
On Sat Sep 30 20:56 , René Berber <firstname.lastname@example.org> sent:
>> This leads me to actually running the server, and my question for the list: Does
>> anyone have experience with that under Cygwin?
>No experience, but I recently did try to use imap-2006a (the latest UW IMAP
release) and it compiles cleanly with no changes but after running for a while it
hits problems with advisory locking (which doesn't exist in Cygwin since it is
using Windows mandatory locking).
So presumably maildir (with courier, rather than mbox with uw-imap) would
somewhat alleviate this problem?
>> Things (like the auth daemon) seem to be failing silently.
>Installed as service?
I can't make it run on the command line or as a service. According to the docs on
the courier site, authdaemond sits around and starts some other processes,
dumping info about it to syslog. When run from the command line as a normal user,
it just exits, not putting anything into /var/log/messages. When run as a
service, /var/log/messages gets:
Sep 30 23:17:21 Package authd: PID 3976: `authd' service stopped, exit status: 5
But I think that is something cygrunsrv outputs, not authdaemond.
>Running under what user & what Windows version?
WinXP SP2, ran on command line as myself, tried as service with default SYSTEM user.
>No messages in the event log (or syslog if you are using it)?
Not for authdaemond (I think).
>Last year there was some report similar to yours:
Yes, incomplete. I posted the configure/make instructions in the hope that it
helps someone else get far enough to help out. :-D
>Dovecot is another server that compiles easily, but their Wiki seems to point to
the same problem with advisory locking under Cygwin.
I didn't realize Dovecot had similar problems to uw-imap. I chose Courier because
it supports maildir and seems to have good reviews.
>As you can see, there are a few of us interested in this subject but, as you
say, there isn't much experience reported.
Would be cool if it was part of the distribution, eventually.
Unsubscribe info: http://cygwin.com/ml/#unsubscribe-simple
Problem reports: http://cygwin.com/problems.html